Skip to content
Sunday, November 15, 2026
InsightBase

The Plan to Reform the Youth Development Structure and Help Young Players

Among my most memorable instances from the season occurred last week, observing a young player charge up the pitch from his defensive 18-yard line to score a winning goal.

Homegrown talents are always appreciated by their team's followers and, based on my observations, the fanbase are going to enjoy many more exceptional moments from him in the time to follow.

Yet, for every player who makes it, there are countless of other boys and girls who don't make it past the various stages, and are forced to cope with a devastating setback at a young age.

It is this group who drop out of youth football that I am concerned about, because I don't think the existing system is sufficient to educate them about their prospects, or care for them when they are discarded.

It demands an transformation and, after I retired, I authored my own report into the youth development pathway, including suggestions for how it could be enhanced.

A Massive Commitment – With Certain Major Benefits

My outlook on academies is not just as a ex- manager. I have family members are in the programme, so I've got a vested concern too.

For all young footballers, the goal of becoming a pro player is a powerful one. The youth development framework has been put in place to give them the greatest chance to realise that ambition, with a specific programme being introduced over a decade ago.

Presently, many thousands of boys are in the system, at teams from the highest division down. It's an all-encompassing regime, with training no less than three evenings a week and a fixtures programme that takes up most of their weekends.

The equivalent framework is now being adopted by the fastest-growing sport, girls football, too.

These setups are manned at exceptional levels and provide work for coaches, physios, doctors and many more administrative staff.

The infrastructure are of the top standard, with world-class indoor and outdoor pitches. Schooling is included too, with tutors hired to run mandatory vocational programmes.

The financial commitment is immense but, as we have seen, the clubs at the pinnacle are reaping major benefits on that outlay through loans and sales of the young players.

How is the Current System?

The main development programme has been in place for around 15 years now, so how has it stood up to the scrutiny of time?

Academies now operate a foundation programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them see through the full programme they would finish at 21. That's more time than a child spends in compulsory education, and lasts his complete childhood.

These kids are issued with team tracksuits and jackets, all badged up, and are identified by peers and family as being associated with that club.

Their sense of self has, practically, been stamped on them at a young age and they also have to make a complete dedication to the academy regime.

That means training on three evenings a week, and a games programme occupying most of the weekend, are now integral to a youngster's aim to chase his ambition.

From my research, in a lot of cases what happens at their studies is seen as being secondary, with the academy becoming dominant and becoming the primary concern of the child and his parents' life.

A number of families see a pot of gold at the end of the journey if their child becomes a professional and heap immense pressure on their backs to succeed.

Unfortunately, statistics show the system has a profound mismatch of achievement and non-achievement. We all see the stars, but we hardly ever see those who are released.

We Must Be Realistic About Their Prospects

I have no desire to strip those aspirations away from aspiring players but we need to be realistic with them about their prospects.

While there are specific individuals a club will identify as being potential professionals, the fact is a large number of the boys have only been on the programme to make up the positions needed for training sessions and the weekend fixtures at each age group.

I genuinely believe academies adequately communicate the hopes of these players or parents, about where they rank in the wider system.

Players and parents should be given a complete breakdown of where they stand, so they can prepare for the likely disappointment when it occurs.

Our academies have nurtured some outstanding talent and there is greater focus paid to player welfare now than in the past, but let's also introduce a bit more priority on openness too.

Increased Focus on Schooling

As I stated above, I feel many youth players joining academies in fact take more notice of their coaches at times than they do of their teachers.

It's crucial this is recognised within the academy system, and youth managers impart this principle to the coaches at every age group.

This phenomenon itself is not novel. Tutelage played a massive part in my development, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in high esteem.

But, for anyone running an academy, they must guarantee the coaches are given unambiguous guidance and awareness of their responsibility because of the influence they have.

Levels of respect, conduct and effort should be as stringent as they are in any school environment – and should extend to the academic side of the child's life there too.

The system I have suggested would have more weight on education and mentoring – for guardians as well as the young players – and also support for what comes next if they are released aged 16.

The Proposal to Help Young Players

I would place academies within several regions, each managed by a head and align them with accredited schools and colleges.

Prior to they get to apprenticeship level, players would be assessed at 14 to see what academic track fits them.

At 16, players starting apprenticeships would begin in a compulsory combined education programme with the academic partners.

At the same time, the players who are let go at 16, can begin a full-time combined academic programme with the schools or colleges.

The benefit for them would be the provision of a new games programme where the schools and colleges would

About the author

Melanie Hartman

Data scientist with over a decade of experience in predictive modeling and AI-driven analytics for Fortune 500 companies.

InsightBase

Type to search articles.